Players average ratings after 12 games

[part time pete]

Average ratings from Martin's reports for players who have started at least four games

7.10 Rose (10 starts)
6.70 Khan (5)
6.63 Tomlinson (4)
6.63 White (4)
6.50 Gordon (9)
6.50 MacDonald (8)
6.45 Benning (10)
6.43 Maynard (7)
6.41 Logan (11)
6.38 Shaughnessy (4)
6.30 Bishop (5)
6.22 Hamilton (9)
6.05 Pearce (10)
6.00 Preston (8)
6.00 Mellis (6)
5.80 Sweeney (10)


Average ratings from the Fans Eggy polls for players who have started at least four games

7.05 Rose (10 starts)
6.59 Gordon (9)
6.57 Khan (5)
6.55 Shaughnessy (4)
6.54 Maynard (7)
6.47 White (4)
6.43 Benning (10)
6.37 Pearce (10)
6.36 MacDonald (8)
6.34 Tomlinson (4)
6.30 Sweeney (10)
6.26 Bishop (5)
6.25 Logan (11)
6.12 Mellis (6)
6.10 Preston (8)
5.95 Hamilton (9)


So in summary Danny Rose tops both lists which isn't surprising.

However Martin gives more than a quarter of a point per game than the fans for Tomlinson and Hamilton

Whereas the Fans give a third of a point per game more than Martin for Pearce and a whole half a point more for Sweeney.

So it looks like Pearce and Sweeney are being given a bit of slack by the fans due to last season's heroics, while Tomlinson and Hamilton are being made scapegoats.

The overall average this season is 6.4pts per game whereas last season the scoring averaged 6.8pts per game.

Both lists surprisingly have the same averages. (6.4 this year and 6.8 last year)

[BigGuy]

Do you need to get out more?

[Chrisuknottm]

Do you need to get out more?

Brilliant BG

[cassellswasmagic]

Shocked at Maccas rating. Anonymous whenever I’ve seen him this season.

[Sneag]

Shocked at Preston's ratings, he' been a liability this season.

Expect him to be off the Bolton in January.

[Tippy Tappy Football]

Psycho Preston is still a very good defender if he can control his recklessness. Has he got some issues off the pitch that need sorting out? Why suddenly start diving in when he did not do it last season? Hopefully Mind Man Drewe will sort him out.

[Tippy Tappy Football]

What are the stats for League games only Pete?

[Spiritater]

Not suprised to see cj where he is, or that that liability preston is towards the bottom.

[wardy12345]

Im surprised Logan and mcdonald have such high ratings.

[part time pete]

What are the stats for League games only Pete?

Surprising very little difference.

The only player who has started four League games whose average score has changed by at least 0.2 pts is Sweeney whose score by Martin's reckoning has gone from an average of 5.80 to 6.00 because his performance against Morecombe in League Cup ( a score of 4) has been removed from the average.

Sweeney's fan score just gone up from 6.30 to 6.36 by removing the Morecambe cup game.

[Stafford]

Do you need to get out more?

Why the need to be a dick? Some people find this interesting.

[Tippy Tappy Football]

Here are the 3,2,1 scores for league games only based on Martin and Stagsnet Ratings

Stagsnet
Danny Rose - 19 points
Conrad Logan - 8
Kellan Gordon - 7
Krystian Pearce - 5
Nicky Maynard - 5

Martin
Danny Rose - 20 points
Conrad Logan - 11
Kellan Gordon - 10
Matt Preston - 7
Alex MacDonald - 7
CJ Hamilton - 7
Nicky Maynard - 7


Top Players Last Season

Stagsnet
Neal Bishop - 48
Krystian Pearce - 44
Tyler Walker - 26
Jacob Mellis - 22
CJ Hamilton - 21

Martin
Krystian Pearce - 53
Neal Bishop - 52
CJ Hamilton - 50
Tyler Walker - 44
Mal Benning - 44
Jacob Mellis - 40